Marginalization and Reform of Religion A Comparative Study of Moses Mendelssohn and Syed Ahmad Khan Section Articles


Zohaib Ahmad


The term marginalization is often used for a community or group which is pushed to the edges of the society through certain social, political, and/or religious restrictions. The history of German Jews and Muslims of the Indian subcontinent stands witness that, to varying degrees over time, they were bound to live on the edges of their respective societies. This discrimination was not just because of their different social, cultural, and political status but religion was also a major factor behind it. In such conditions, Moses Mendelssohn and Syed Ahmad Khan worked for the betterment of their respective Jewish and Muslim communities. Although the work of both scholars is a recurring theme of discussion in the academic world, still there is no study available in which their efforts have been compared. By presenting a feature by feature comparison of the works of both scholars, the current paper first figures out their methodology and then explores their motive behind using pure reason to interpret sacred scriptures. It is also argued that there are fewer differences and more commonalities in their works. Their primary aim was to equip their people with modern education, since they thought that through educational reform they would be able to improve the social, political, and economic conditions of their people. Although they achieved noteworthy success, their efforts changed the religious direction of their people. Especially after the reform of Mendelssohn, a significant number of Jews distanced themselves from their ancestral religion.


How to Cite
Zohaib Ahmad. (2019). Marginalization and Reform of Religion. Journal of Islamic Thought and Civilization (JITC), 9(2), 172-193.


Abdulhaq. Tafsīr Fatḥ-ul Mannān. Lahore: Al-Faisal, 2009.
Addleson, Abraham. The Epic of a People: The Story of the Jews. New York: Bloch Publishing Company, 1946.
Ben-Rafael, Eliezer, Yosef Gorny, and Judit Bokser Liwerant. Jews and Jewish Education in Germany Today. Leiden: Brill, 2011.
Bhatti, Muhammad Ishaq. Brrēsaghīr maiṇ Musalmānōṇ kē Awwalīn Nuqūsh. Lahore: Maktabah Salfīyyah, 1990.
Bildersee, Adele. Jewish Post-Biblical History through Great Personalities from Jochanan ben Zakkai through Moses Mendelssohn. New York: Union of American Hebrew Congregations, 2003.
Brady, Thomas A., and Chickering Roger. Jews, Judaism, and the Reformation in Sixteenth-Century Germany. Boston: Brill Publication, 2006.
Brown, Michael L. Authentic Fire: A Response to John MacArthur's Strange Fire. Lake Mary: Creation House, 2015.
Carlebach, Elisheva. Divided Souls: Converts From Judaism in Germany, 1500–1750. London: Yale University, 2001.
Chand, Tara. Tārīkh Taḥrīk-i Āzād-i Hind Vol. 1, New Delhi: National Council for Promotion of Urdu Language, 1998.
Elkins, Dov Peretz. Shepherd of Jerusalem. Bloomington: AuthorHouse, 2005.
Graetz, H., and B. Lowy. History of the Jews: From the Chmielnicki Persecution of the Jews in Poland (1648 C. E. ) to the Period of Emancipation in Cent. New York: Cosimo, Incorporated, 2009.
Graham, Colonel. G. F. I. The Life and Work of Syed Ahmed Khan. London: William Blackwod and Sons, 1923.
Gritsch, Eric W. Martin Luther's Anti-Semitism: Against His Better Judgment. Cambridge: Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2012.
Ḥālī, Alṭāf Ḥusain. Ḥayāt-i Jāvēd. New Delhi: National Council for Promotion of Urdu Language, 1999.
Hillman, Susanne. "The Conversions of Dorothea Mendelssohn: Conviction or Convenience?". German Studies Review 29, no. 1 (2006): 127-44.