Christian-Muslim Relations in the Second Half of 19th Century India in View of Syed Nāṣir-ul-Dīn Muḥammad Abūlmanṣūr Dehlvī (d. 1903)

Keywords: Christian-Muslim relations, Christian-Muslim polemics, intricate relationships, religious polemics, Syed Nāṣir-ul-Dīn Muḥammad Abūlmanṣūr Dehlvī

Abstract

Abstract Views: 0

The current study examined the nature of Christian-Muslim relationships in 19th-century India. It is argued that their relationships were largely shaped in the context of the polemical debates that were developed to defend the teachings and tenets of their respective religions. Syed Nāṣir-ul-Dīn Muḥammad Abūlmanṣūr Dehlvī (d. 1903) was a polemical Muslim writer who wrote approximately 25 books in the refutation of Christianity. He also defended the religion of Islam; however, his work remains in oblivion. The primary objective of the current research was to analyse Dehlvī's major works dedicated to refute Christianity and to assess their significance. This research holds importance under two key reasons. Firstly, it sheds light on the nature of Christian-Muslim relationships during the 19th century and secondly, it highlights the significance of Muslim writings about other religions, particularly Christianity, in the modern world. The research concluded that while the polemical technique, due to its confrontational aspect, may no longer be the primary method of religious studies. The texts, however, generated through this approach can still be significant resources for students and academics since they offer opportunities for critical thinking, historical investigation, and a better understanding of intricate relationships that exist between religious traditions. Therefore, polemical writings play a significant role in advancing the academic knowledge in the field of religious studies.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Ali, Farman., and Humaira Ahmad. “Contextualizing Christian Theology in South Asia: An Analytical Study from 1542-1947.” Journal of Islamic Thought and Civilization 9, no. 2 (2019): 272–297.

Ali, Farman., and Humaira Ahmad. “A Study of the Inter-Religious Dialogue through Syed Ahmad’s Reconciliatory Approaches in Tabīn-ul-Kalām.” Al-Milal Journal of Religion and Thought 3 no. 1 (2021):168-189.

Ali, Farman. “Contemporizing Christian Theological Trends in Pakistan: An Analytical Critique of Christian Discourses since 1970.” PhD thesis: University of Management and Technology, Lahore, 2020.

Barkatullah, Padari. Salib kay ‘Alambardar (The Cross Bearers). Lahore: Punjab Religious Book Society, 2nd Edition, 1857.

Dehlvī, Syyed Nāṣir-ul-Dīn Muḥammad Abulmanṣūr. In‘ᾱm-e-‘Aam fī Rad-e-Ala Aina-e-Islām li Rajab (A General Reward in the Refutation of the Mirror of Islam by Rajab). Delhi: Matba‘-e-Faruqi, 1290 AH/1873 CE.

Dehlvī, Syyed Nāṣir-ul-Dīn Muḥammad Abūlmanṣūr. Mīzān-ul-Mīzᾱn fī Rad-e-Ala Mīzᾱn-ul-Ḥaq li Pfander (The Balance of the Balance in the Refutation of the Balance of Truth by Pfander). Delhi: Matbu‘a Nusrat-ul-Matabi‘, 1882.

Dehlvī, Syyed Nāṣir-ul-Dīn Muḥammad Abūlmanṣūr. Navīd-e-Jᾱved (The Eternal Good News). Delhi: Noor Muḥammad Malik Kakhana Tijarat Kutub, 1929.

Dehlvī, Syyed Nāṣir-ul-Dīn Muḥammad Abūlmanṣūr. Taṣḥiḥ al-Tāwīl fī Rad-e-Alā Tafsīr al-Mukāshfah (Correction of the Interpretation in the Refutation of the Interpretation of the Book of Revelation). Delhi: Matbu‘a Nusrat-ul-Matabi‘, n.d.

Dehlvī, Syyed Nᾱṣir-ul-Dīn Abulmanṣūr. ‘Aqūbat-ul-Ḍālīn fī rad ‘Alā Hidayat-ul-Muslimīn lī Imād-ul-Dīn (The Punishment for those who Astray in the Refutation of Direction to Muslims by Imad-ul-Din). Delhi: Nusrat-ul-Matabi, 1324 Hijri/1906.

Dehlvī, Syyed Nᾱṣir-ul-Dīn Abulmanṣūr. Namūna-e-Taḥrīf (The Alteration Pattern). Delhi: Matbu‘a Nusrat-ul-Matabi‘, n.d.

Pfander, Karl Gottlieb. Mīzān-ul-Ḥaq (The Balance of Truth). London: Temple Bar, 3rd edition, 1832, 1862.

Powell, Avril Ann. “Contact and Controversy between Islam and Christianity in Northern India, 1833-1857: The Relations between Muslims and Protestant Missionaries in the North-Western Provinces and Oudh.” Doctoral Dissertation: University of London, 1983.

Rahi, Akhtar. “Syyed Nᾱṣir-ul-Dīn Muḥammad Abūlmanṣūr Dehlvī aur Masīḥī-Muslim Munāẓratī Adab (Syyed Nāṣir-ul-Dīn Muḥammad Abūlmanṣūr Dehlvī and Christian-Muslim Polemical Literature),” Alam-e-Islam aur Isaiyyat 2, no 7 (1992): 5-14.

Wherry, Elwood Morris. The Muslim Controversy: Being a Review of Christian Literature Written in the Urdu Language for the Propagation of the Christian Religion and the Refutation of Islam. London: Christian Literature Society, 1905.

Published
2023-12-06
How to Cite
Ali, Farman. 2023. “Christian-Muslim Relations in the Second Half of 19th Century India in View of Syed Nāṣir-Ul-Dīn Muḥammad Abūlmanṣūr Dehlvī (d. 1903)”. Journal of Islamic Thought and Civilization 13 (2), 152-63. https://doi.org/10.32350/jitc.132.10.
Section
Articles